Does This Rhino Drone Video Help or Hurt Conservation?

Does This Rhino Drone Video Help or Hurt Conservation?

22-year old professional drone racing pilot Johnny Schaer has built a strong social media following on Instagram and YouTube with visually stunning video capture from his custom built drones. His skill level is piloting the drone is jaw dropping, and his scene visualization and video editing skills are also really advanced as seen in this video taken with permission in Saudi Arabia.

Schaer, who goes by “Johnny FPV,” recently visited a game preserve in South Africa with the Rhino Rescue Project, an organization that combats poaching by injecting material into rhino horns, which “renders it useless for ornamental or medicinal use.” And posted this incredible video of two stampeding rhinos first on Facebook, and then on Instagram.

 

His caption (which has been edited since its initial post) reads in part:

“These Rhinos are being killed and pushed toward extinction for their horns which provide no medicinal value. The two Rhinos seen In the video were near a road that is actively used by poachers, and under the supervision of Vetpaw and the private game reserve, we used the drone try and push them to a safer area. While this shot turned out beautiful, I should not have flown this close to the animals. This is not a responsible way to film wild life [sic].”

The Rhino Rescue Project also posted the video to their Instagram account, and multiple commenters questioned whether the drone was intrusive or harmful. The Project’s answer partially contradicts Schaer’s by implying that the animals weren’t bothered.

I am not an African wildlife biologist, and my attempt to contact specialists at the  WWF was unsuccessful at the time of publishing. So it’s speculative to assess whether or not the rhinos were at risk as a result of this video capture (although they indisputably have very acute hearing).

Using visuals to advocate for conservationism has become commonplace. Veteran photojournalist Ami Vitale has focused many of her recent efforts on elephant and rhino conservation in Africa with images like these:

View this post on Instagram

Photo by @amivitale. It is devastating to hear that China has decided to reverse its 25-year-old ban on the sale and use of rhinoceros and tiger products. The reversal allows for these products to be used in medical research or healing, uses long since proven to have no benefits to humans. This change will certainly lead to more pressure on already terribly vulnerable animal populations and further endanger the conservationists, rangers and communities who fight for the survival of these majestic creatures. Here, Sudan, the last living male Northern White Rhino left on this planet is comforted moments before he passed away March 19, 2018 in northern Kenya. Sudan was brought to Kenya from @safari_park_dvur_kralove in the #CzechRepublic in 2009. He died surrounded by people who loved him at @olpejeta and has been an inspirational figure for many across the world. If there is any meaning in his death, it's that Sudan can be our final wake up call. In a world of 7 billion, we need to start recognizing that we are not separate from nature. When we see ourselves as part of the landscape and part of nature, then saving nature is really about saving ourselves. Today, fewer 30,000 rhinos and 3,900 tigers remain in the wild. We are witnessing extinction on our watch and must help them by speaking out and supporting conservation efforts worldwide, especially among the indigenous communities who are on the front lines every day against poaching. Follow @olpejeta @safari_park_dvur_kralove @conservationorg @nature_africa and others to learn more and get involved. @everydayextinction @kenyawildlifeservice @thephotosociety @natgeo @natgeoimagecollection #LastManStanding #SudanForever #WorthMoreAlive #OlPejetaRhinos #NorthernWhiteRhinos #protectrhinos #DontLetThemDisappear #rhinos #saverhinos #stoppoaching #kenya#northernkenya #africa #everydayafrica #photojournalism #nikonusa #nikon #nikonambassador #nikonnofilter #amivitale

A post shared by Ami Vitale (@amivitale) on

View this post on Instagram

Congratulations to my dear friend, veterinarian Pete Morkel, shown here with one of the last northern white rhinos back in 2009 at @safari_park_dvur_kralove in the #CzechRepublic before they were brought to @olpejeta conservancy in Kenya. Pete won the Prince William Award for Conservation in Africa, 2018 last week given by @tusk_org. I've known Pete for almost 10 years and the man is one of my greatest inspirations. He has committed his entire life to saving wildlife all over this planet and “shown complete disregard for his personal safety, whilst spending many months at a time away from his family dedicating his entire energy and attention to the conservation and welfare of Africa’s wildlife." The Telegraph writes, “You’re always taking a few blows here and there,” he laughs. He works in some of the world’s least stable countries, in areas infested by armed poachers or rebel groups like the Lord’s Resistance Army or uncleared mines. He once fractured his skull when his Cessna crashed. He reckons he has immobilised 10,000 animals. Inevitably a few have died. “Success and failure are just a heartbeat away from each other,” he says. “It can be gutting. I’ve had my share of failure and you just have to pick up and keep going and learn from what went wrong.” #gratitude #tuskawards #tusktrust #conservation #africa

A post shared by Ami Vitale (@amivitale) on

Documentaries like the acclaimed Blue Planet series have used drones, light aircraft and other innovative mechanisms to capture wildlife in a way never seen before:

Schaer’s video is visually on par with Blue Planet. And yet, the Schaer footage leaves me unsettled mostly because of the context and the risk of mimicry.

Context

The audience for Blue Planet or photographers like Paul Nicklen (a photography and biologist) arguably understand the context of what they are seeing – namely, that it was captured by subject matter experts in an effort to advocate for the environment, natural ecosystems and wildlife. Everyone wants eyeballs on their work, but for people like Vitale, there’s a consistency and purpose-driven reason to every post.

By contrast, Schaer’s work has been primarily driven by visual eye candy and “tourism.” His work in Saudi Arabia resulted in a single video in a single location with no explanation of historical significance. Instead, he likens the environment to Star Wars.

His efforts to try to raise awareness about rhino poaching should be applauded, but if it’s a single visit with a single video, then he’s playing the role of tourist. There’s nothing wrong with this approach to photography/videography per se, but the work will undoubtedly influence the behavior of others.

Mimicry

The rise in popularity of Urbex (urban exploration) has been fueled in large part by the dramatic photos shared on social media like this:

Or the ubiquitous “legs dangling off a building” photo:

The desire to mimic these images leads photographers to take unnecessary (sometimes fatal) risks. The photos look awesome, but capturing them is irresponsible and often illegal.

Schaer worked with a wildlife group and with the permission of the land owner, and even then, he admits that he worked too closely to the animals. But the video travels without context. Many viewers will simply think it’s cool, and some will want to replicate the footage without the benefit of working with game wardens, wildlife biologists, et al. They might use larger, noisier drones. They might be less skilled operators but still try to get as close. They might try capturing footage of critically endangered species and literally imperil the animal.

It’s a legitimate question to ask whether Schaer’s footage is actually raising awareness of rhino poaching, or whether it’s just visual clickbait. On a critically important issue that requires deep engagement, understanding and action, most of the engagement Schaer has generated has been a double tap of the screen and a +1 in the “likes” column.

 

Next Post:
Previous Post:
This article was written by

Allen Murabayashi is the Chairman and co-founder of PhotoShelter.

There are 6 comments for this article
  1. Cristian at 4:14 pm

    Definetely helps conservation. The little stress a drone causes is nothing against the impact of such footage to the audience. Congratulations to Mr Schaer for his wonderful footage and showing us the marvels of nature with this incredible point of view. I am sure quite a lot of people will be positive affected seeing this beatiful creatures running free, that unfortunately are very endangered and not precisely by drone pilots……..

  2. TheRock at 10:35 pm

    I really don’t know how to judge the impact. On a scale of getting killed for their horns to a drone chase, a few minutes of drone chasing is a minuscule event in the rhino’s lives. Even better if this exposure does indeed drive more awareness and get more rangers hired nationwide and into the reserves in the many African countries to repel the poachers. I have been to a couple of South Africa’s main rhino preserves and I know for a fact the rampant poaching is a huge problem. But if everyone starts bringing drones to the continent to get slo-mo chases of African creatures, even if they are on preserves, it could add up to a lot of needless stress for the creatures. I can see Allen’s point there. This can extend to wild mustangs or buffalo herds in the US and really wildlife everywhere. Warhol talked about everyone getting their 15-minutes of fame back in the ’60s. With Facebook, Instagram, etc, every clip gets its 15-minutes now too and then seems lost in the great shuffle of the web. With so much social media and constant postings of thousands of clips per second, it is hard to see a long-range value of a single clip. If this is part of a youtube story, documentary or series on endangered creatures, I can see it fitting in much better and having some results. Tough call. It is a beautiful clip and I enjoy watching them in full stride. Usually, they aren’t so full on.

  3. Greg at 8:39 am

    I am an avid FPV drone builder and pilot. I fly rigs from whoop size, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6” FPV (goggles) and up to DJI aerial photography drones. I can guarantee that this was NOT a “20cm silent drone”- at a minimum it was a drone swinging 5 or 6 inch props to be able to carry a GoPro 7 at that speed and smoothness- VERY LOUD!!!! Johny knew this was wrong. This “conservation” effort is completely wrong- the animals were visibly terrified. The rhinos could have been herded much more humanely by vehicle. This was an opportunistic attempt with an interest in getting (glorious) footage taking precedence over the welfare of the rhinos- I hope the WWF gets involved because we in the drone community don’t need more idiots attempting this and the animals definitely do nothing to deserve being chased by something that sounds like a screaming banshee- if you don’t know search for some raw FPV footage on YouTube to hear what it sounds like. Shameful.

    • Cristian at 12:10 pm

      “Opportunistic””more “idiots””visibly terrified”………before making misjudgements and accusations take a nice cup of tea. You really need it dude.

  4. Pamela Kelso at 8:35 pm

    I’m not sure what a terrified rhino looks like. Is a drone more terrifying than being shot and having body parts hacked off while you are still alive?

    From the rhino’s standpoint of view was it a very noisy bird? I’ve seen videos of them turn on a dime and face down and attack something they thought was a danger. The movie Hatari. I know, the movie was abusive and John Wayne is a dolt in it but it portrays them as several tons of anger on four legs with a large horn if they feel threatened. I think to clip would aid conservation.

    The bigger danger is fools (someone else’s term above) who will try to copy it and the worst possible danger is Chinas wrongheaded decision to end their ban on the horns.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *